男孩的包皮环切术:必要还是有益?

Picture of Dr Nada Sudhakaran

Dr Nada Sudhakaran

Paediatric Surgeon & Urologist

非多余 含密集性神经 包皮若无问题可不割

Originally published in Easily Sin Chew on 2023-02-18
https://easily.sinchew.com.my/node/4620/

医句话:

在马来西亚,大多数男孩基于宗教或文化,必须经历割礼仪式,医学上称之为包皮环切手术。若无面对紧急医疗事故,应避免此手术。割包皮好处是可预防如龟头炎等疾病,也可降低泌尿道感染及性病传播的风险。在孩子步入青春期时,家长让他们自行决定是否动此手术。

Originally published in Easily Sin Chew on 2023-02-18
https://easily.sinchew.com.my/node/4620/

“相信大家对包皮环切手术(circumcision)不陌生,男性包皮环切手术指的是通过手术切除阴茎的部分或全部包皮。对于马来西亚的大多数男孩而言,进行此手术多是基于宗教或文化的原因,也就是民间所称的‘割礼’。

根据传统,这项盛行多年的割礼仪式是在青春期进行,以作为进入成年的一种标志。

排除上述原因,有两种情况是以医疗因素介入,而给患者施予包皮环切手术,一是包皮发生病理性的变化或皮肤异常,一般是疤痕或增厚;二则是继发性感染或创伤。这些病因发生的几率为0.1%。

包茎或包皮过长 勃起痛
在出生时,大多数初生男婴阴茎包皮无法缩至龟头(阴茎头)后方,这种情况是一种生理上自然且正常的现象。在医学上,我们称之为包茎(phimosis),也就是俗称的‘包皮过长’。此病症有可能会导致勃起疼痛和引起性功能问题。

一般上,5岁的男孩会出现上述现象,占10%;约5%的10岁男孩亦会面对这个问题。然而在男孩长至青春期时,面对包茎问题者仅1%。这1%的男孩在10至12岁左右的青春期间进行一次评估,并可从环切包皮手术中受益。

另一方面,一般上,正常的包皮会分泌出油脂类分泌物及一些坏死细胞,经长年累月,这些细胞有可能堆积在包皮下,久而久之就会形成一种白色的乳酪状物质,即包皮垢(smegma),尤其是发生阴茎包皮无法缩至龟头后方,或是长期没有清洗下,包皮垢就更容易产生。

包皮垢引发感染
包皮垢形成后又没有清理,这有可能会引发感染。若受到感染,父母可让孩子坐在装有温盐水的水桶里,并按照医生指示及处方,涂抹抗生素成分的药膏,大致上数天后即能康复。

我必须提醒父母的是,你应该教导家中的男孩,在洗澡或排尿时缩回包皮,并且清洗包皮,保持干净,通过这样的习惯,才能避免感染。

那达医生(Nada Sudhakaran)
儿童外科顾问

居多发达国家摒弃割礼

除却宗教因素,如无面对紧急医疗的情况下,包皮环切手术是可避免的。

从前在美国,大多数的男孩在出生时都需要进行割礼,而现今的大部分发达国家正摒弃这项仪式。

首先,我们必须了解到,包皮是一种复杂、具特殊性的组织。它是一个皮肤、粘膜和肌肉移动性双层褶皱,其中含有密集的性神经末梢,并且是阴茎皮肤系统中重要的部分,并非是多余且额外的‘东西’。

或致尿道口变窄
包皮是有作用的,它可保持龟头的柔软;反之,切除包皮则会形成角质,变厚变硬。

其实,包皮环切手术非常疼痛,尤其在新生儿身上进行时,局部麻醉不足以达到完全的麻醉效果。

再加上,手术后的伤口受到粪便、尿液与纸尿片的刺激,婴儿在伤口愈合期间会有持续性的疼痛。纸尿布也有可能造成尿道口变窄(或称为尿道口异常狭窄);新生儿在接受包皮手术后,母乳喂养与亲子关系亦可能会受到影响。

世卫:降低性病传播

割包皮手术将会破坏包皮的保护力与性功能。手术并发症的病例尽管发生甚少,但我们不排除其可能性,如出血、感染、管口窄狭、粘连、死亡和阴茎某部分脱落。有些病人可能会出现过量或过少的皮肤。

正常的包皮受感染或发生并发症的风险率为0.1%,然而,术后并发症的风险率为1%。

如果包皮过长,割除包皮可以减少传染,亦能改善勃起疼痛问题。

总的来说,做好日常的包皮清洁工作可以减少风险,同时成年后实行安全的性行为,亦可避免性病的传播,这一切是否能达到良好的成效,皆与教育、醒觉和自我保健有着非常密切的关系。

包皮环切手术也并非全无益处,对于一些病症仍起到一定的正面效果,其一是预防龟头炎(balanitis)、龟头包皮炎(balanoposthitis)、包茎及嵌顿性包茎(paraphimosis);其二保持阴茎的清洁;其三减低两种风险,即泌尿道感染及性病的传播。世界卫生组织建议此手术以降低性病传播风险。

女性割礼不具任何益处

究竟该不该进行包皮环切手术,这个争论仍在持续,其实保留包皮亦是个人的选择。

以我个人的看法是,我们应该避免给婴儿进行这个手术,直到你的孩子能够对自己的身体作出决定的年龄时,即青春期,让他选择进行包皮环切手术。这正是与马来西亚在实行传统文化割礼的年龄一致。

必须一提的是,女性割礼是指生殖器切割,我认为这种做法是不恰当的,因为女性割礼根本不具任何益处。此手术是一种用针刺破皮肤的刺穿手术,会造成出血、疼痛,给孩子带来不必要的创伤之余,最后也会在皮肤伤处留下难看的疤痕。在做此手术前,父母得慎重考量是否真有这个必要。”

Share this Post

Search Blog Posts

Dr Nada Sudhakaran

Paediatric Surgeon & Urologist

Paediatric Surgeon

Hospitals

Languages Spoken

Clinics Available

Pantai Hospital Kuala Lumpur

+603-2296 0419

Assunta Hospital PJ

+603-7872 3000

Follow Dr. Nada On Social

Patient Testimonials

Dr Nada Child Surgeon (Kuala Lumpur)Dr Nada Child Surgeon (Kuala Lumpur)4.9 Based on 237 reviews fromSee all reviewsmichelle alverinamichelle alverina ★★★★★ Oh dr Nada is the best. His explanation is very detail, easy to understand & relieving . He’s very good with kids as well. Love to recommend dr Nada to every parents who need to consult with pediatry urology specialist!Stefvifans StefvifansStefvifans Stefvifans ★★★★★ The Doctor so friendly and explain things so clearly. He explained to us so detail until we understood what happenedFaidhi SobriFaidhi Sobri ★★★★★ Thank you Dr for 2 years recovery process for my son. Alhamdulillah everything went well for first and 2nd stage surgery. He is a very experience Dr for kids surgery and recommended to allSiti Zolkafli86Siti Zolkafli86 ★★★★★ “I am very satisfied with the service from Dr Nada. The doctor is very professional, explains the condition clearly and in an easy-to-understand way. The consultation was comfortable and not awkward. Highly recommended!nadia novaranadia novara ★★★★★ Pernah bawa anak Operasi hipospadia dengan dokter nada di KL.Dokternya baik, kasih alternatif agar biaya operasi bisa lebih murah gimana. Sangat membantu. Dokternya juga Ramah. Pokoknya oke 👍Aida RamliAida Ramli ★★★★★ Love dr nadarajan. Very good with kids and asnwer all questions we had. Also always abailable if we have any questionssyaqir wahabsyaqir wahab ★★★★★ Doktor yang sangat berpengalaman.shada ikramshada ikram ★★★★★ Glad we came here! Dr Nada provided the correct treatment based on my son’s condition. The explanation was clear, and we have seen good improvement since.Tim TalbotTim Talbot ★★★★★ Excellent from beginning to start. Dr Nada is gentle, clear regarding treatment and genuinely cared for our child - with the end result, a successful and minimally invasive surgery. We couldn't have been happier with the treatment.Thank you so much!Hishiko TVHishiko TV ★★★★★ 很细心,很友善的医生!eddy chineddy chin ★★★★★ Highly recommended. Dr. Nada is very attentive and thorough.Simbar DubeSimbar Dube ★★★★★ My son recently had a keyhole surgery performed by Dr. Nada, and I cannot speak highly enough about the experience.From the very beginning, Dr. Nada was calm, reassuring, and incredibly kind. As a parent, it is naturally stressful when your child needs surgery, but he took the time to explain everything clearly and made sure we felt comfortable and informed throughout the process. His professionalism and confidence immediately built trust.What stood out the most was how he treated my son. Instead of approaching the situation in a purely clinical way, he connected with him on a human level. He spoke to him kindly, made him feel safe, and after the procedure he even gave him a teddy bear. That small gesture meant a lot. It turned what could have been a frightening experience for a child into something much more comforting.The surgery itself went very well, and the care we received from Dr. Nada and the team was excellent. It is clear that he not only has great skill as a surgeon, but also genuine compassion for his patients.I am deeply grateful for the care he provided to my son, and I would highly recommend Dr. Nada to any parent looking for a skilled and caring doctor.esther kah yanesther kah yan ★★★★★ Dr Nada is a very detailed doctor in which he explained all the conditions to me about my baby, before deciding to have surgery. And also he will patiently teach us how to exercise for my baby, for post-surgery recovery purpose. Strongly recommend this doctor to all the parents if your baby is having tongue tie issue.Ashraf RafiuddinAshraf Rafiuddin ★★★★★ Good doctor. Very friendly. Good with children. Successfully completed a surgery for my 1 year old baby boydessy tandessy tan ★★★★★ Dr Nada is so communicative and a good doctorMánarina NájibMánarina Nájib ★★★★★ Pengalaman yang baik Doktor yang peramah dan explaination yang bagusWeng Soon ThamWeng Soon Tham ★★★★★ Wonderful experience with Dr Nada. We had concerns with our child but reassurance was given after a detailed examination and consultation. Reassured us surgery is not needed and adviced us what we could do to help resolve the issue. Very kind and gentle doctor. Would highly recommend!Nazihah MNNazihah MN ★★★★★ ​We couldn't have asked for a better experience with Dr Nadarajan for our son's hypospadias repair. From the initial consultation through the recovery process, the care was exceptional. The 2 stages surgeries was a success, and all of our follow-up appointments were incredibly smooth and reassuring. Most importantly, the doctor made us feel informed every step of the way. We are so grateful! Thank you very much Dr. Nada and his assistant, Su for the great service.izzaty nizamizzaty nizam ★★★★★ Alhamdulillah consultation dengan Dr Nada sgt membantu. X jadi operate hydrocele. Tengok next year, Harap perubahan lebih baik.Felix HermantoFelix Hermanto ★★★★★ Terima kasih Dokter Nada sudah mengobati hernia dengan sempurnaDokter sangat ramah dan menjelaskan dengan teliti dan jelasTerima kasih juga sudah memperbaiki sunat anak saya dengan baikSiah Yee PingSiah Yee Ping ★★★★★ 这个医生很厉害,很细心👍👍👍Regina LoireRegina Loire ★★★★★ The doctor is very great, my child was lucky to meet Doctor Nada, his hernia was curedSyafa AnnasyaSyafa Annasya ★★★★★ Anak laki2 saya Muhammad Syaqif Alfarizqi 2x melakukan operasi undesensus testis bilateral bersama dr Nada, Best dr 🥰 terimakasi dr 🙏🙏DelbertDelbert ★★★★★ My son (1 year old) has a Hernia and we came from Indonesia for a treatment and doctor suggested an operation.Before the operation, doctor has explained in detail how the operation works and what effects may (very rarely) occur.H+1 After the operation was done my son doesn’t feel pain and can return to normal activitiesThe doctor very friendly and informative. We are so grateful can meet doctor NadaDavid LimDavid Lim ★★★★★ Hi i am from indonesia, my son 1 years old get Hernia inguinal , and got surgery by doctor Nada. Doctor Nada is a best doctor i ever meet , he very patient to explain all the information and process of surgery before the surgery. The surgery is success and my son dont even feel pain at all after the operation, thankyou very much doctorYosie NovianliusYosie Novianlius ★★★★★ We're almost hopeless before meeting Dr. Nada, imagining that our 12-month-old baby might need surgery due to a diagnosis of UDT/retractile testis.However, we found new hope after meeting Dr. Nada. He is very friendly, calming, and took the time to explain everything clearly to us. He even drew diagrams and showed us his article, explaining that our son’s condition does not require surgery and is completely normal.We were extremely relieved.Additionally, our 12-month-old nephew underwent surgery twice with Dr. Nada, and both procedures were a great success.Ashraf MakkiAshraf Makki ★★★★★ I cannot express enough gratitude to Dr. Nadarajan for the exceptional care he provided to my son. He performed a laparoscopic hernia repair with incredible precision and skill.​From the very first consultation, Dr. Nadarajan was professional, patient, and highly reassuring. He took the time to explain the procedure in detail, which put our minds at ease. The surgery was a complete success, thanks to his great expertise in minimally invasive techniques.​What truly sets him apart is his outstanding bedside manner. His follow-up care before and after the surgery was exemplary; and he ensured my son's recovery was on track. We are truly blessed to have found such a brilliant and surgeon. Highly recommendedHelen YaoHelen Yao ★★★★★ Dr. Nada is a very kind and patient doctor. My 10-year-old son went to the emergency department with abdominal pain and had difficulty describing what he was feeling. Dr. Nada was excellent at guiding him to express his pain clearly. We highly recommend Dr. Nada to other parents.Hazwan MustafaHazwan Mustafa ★★★★★ Experienced. Making wise and fast suggestions to us. Thank you Dr.Ben ben baliBen ben bali ★★★★★ Dr Nada's explanation is very clear and answers our questions one by one. He is very Kind and expert, the operation is a success and the child after the operation can walk without feeling too much pain. Thank You Doctor Nada🙏🏻😊👍👍IENA AZLINAIENA AZLINA ★★★★★ Heartfelt thanks to Dr. Nada for his gentle care and reassurance throughout my daughter’s appendix surgery. Your kindness made all the difference. 💖FromDhia Zara Batrisyadzulkifli azizdzulkifli aziz ★★★★★ We went to see Dr Nada due to hernia on my kid but after evaluation it was hydrocele case. The procedure was done in a daycare ward. It was smooth & fast.Dr Nada team were friendly and professional. Thank you Dr for treating my child. Recommended paeds surgeon in Pantai.Siti HadijahSiti Hadijah ★★★★★ Thank you Dr Nada. My baby was born premature at 28 weeks and had been intubated for a long time in the NICU. Before the hernia repair, he was less active, but after the surgery he became so much more cheerful, active, and had a better appetite. The procedure only took about 30–40 minutes, and Dr. Nada was extremely kind and gentle with him. He was actually my second opinion, and I finally felt confident to proceed with the keyhole surgery after meeting him. It was a smooth procedure with less pain and a fast recovery. What I really appreciate is that I could directly WhatsApp him anytime if I had any questions. He always responds kindly and patiently. Truly grateful for her excellent care. 💖NadineNadine ★★★★★ Dr. Nada was absolutely wonderful with my child. He took the time to chat with him in a friendly and humorous way, which really helped my son feel comfortable. His kindness and approach made the whole visit a positive experience.Khai MingKhai Ming ★★★★★ I recently brought my son to Dr. Nada for laparoscopic keyhole surgery for his hernia. The surgery itself went smoothly, and thanks to Dr. Nada's expertise, our son recovered much faster than we expected. Most importantly, my son was back to his usual active self in no time, and we even noticed he became more energetic and less grumpy after the procedure. I highly recommend Dr. Nada to any parent looking for a surgeon who combines professional excellence with compassion.Maznina Lee Faizal LeeMaznina Lee Faizal Lee ★★★★★ Best dpt jumpa Dr.Nada, selalu tengok dekat TT je.. penerangan yg jelas.. dari nervous jadi tenang.. Dr.Nada pandai ambil hati anak, so anak pon tak nangis.. sebelum Dr.Nada nak explain dia kasi ank tenang2 kt belakang tu..so mak2 ni dapatlah focus apa doktor nak cakap.. pepun sangat happy.. thank you Dr. Nada.Jcp YeapJcp Yeap ★★★★★ Dr. Nada is wonderful – very friendly and cheerful. He takes the time to explain everything clearly and always makes sure I feel at ease during the consultation. I truly value his expertise, and I wouldn’t hesitate to recommend him to other.Pavittra Mohan PillaiPavittra Mohan Pillai ★★★★★ We brought our baby (6 months+) to Dr. Nada’s clinic for a tongue tie release, and I cannot thank him enough. Dr. Nada was extremely thorough, caring, and professional throughout the whole process. Looking back, I wish we had done this much earlier when my baby was under a month old—it would have made my breastfeeding journey so much smoother.After the release, we immediately noticed a big difference. My baby feeds much better now, drinking milk from the bottle is easier, and swallowing solids has also improved within a few days. I’m also hopeful to see her relatch soon.Thank you, Dr. Nada, for guiding us through this journey and for your genuine care. I highly recommend Dr. Nada and his clinic to any parent considering a tongue tie release for their baby.Siti AnisdaSiti Anisda ★★★★★ Dear Dr. Nada, Dr Chong, Assunta Team and Pantai Team,I and husband just wanted to extend our sincere gratitude for the excellent care you provided during my son's tongue-tie procedure on 23 September 2025. Your professionalism, kindness, and reassuring approach made a world of difference during what could have been a stressful time for us.Thank you for making both my son and us as parents feel comfortable and well taken care of. We truly appreciate your expertise and compassion.♥️♥️♥️Nichole TanNichole Tan ★★★★★ Doctor very good 👍👍👍VIVEK SASHEENDRANVIVEK SASHEENDRAN ★★★★★ I had a very pleasant experience with Dr Nada. Special needs son had an emergency due to an infection In the gut.Direshkumar PadmanathanDireshkumar Padmanathan ★★★★★ Dr. Nada is very good at handling kids and always very helpful. He makes children feel comfortable and explains things clearly to parents. Highly recommended!js_loader

Latest Posts

Schedule An Appointment

Set up an appointment with Dr. Nada and he’ll be able to assess your child to ensure they receive the care they need.

Or fill up the form below

Clinic Locations & Hours

Pantai Hospital
(Kuala Lumpur)
Assunta Hospital
(Petaling Jaya)

Stay Informed About Your Child's Health - For FREE!

Subscribe to my EMAIL newsletter and receive occassional emails from me containing my latest articles and videos about paediatric health matters that can help your child lead a safe and healthy life.