Circumcision – is it necessary or beneficial for boys in Malaysia?

Picture of Dr Nada Sudhakaran

Dr Nada Sudhakaran

Paediatric Surgeon & Urologist

Circumcision – is it necessary or beneficial for boys in Malaysia?

IMPORTANT: This article only discusses the MEDICAL reasons to circumcise or otherwise. It expresses no opinion on religious/cultural reasons for circumcision which are common in Malaysia.

Male Circumcision involves surgical removal of part or all of the foreskin of the penis. For the majority of boys in Malaysia, this is done for religious or cultural reasons, traditionally conducted just before puberty as a passage to manhood.

Your son’s penis & foreskin – possible complications

At birth most baby boys’ foreskin cannot be retracted over his glans penis (head of penis). This is normal and called physiological (natural) phimosis.

At about 5 years of age about 10 % of boys are unable to do so and at age 10 around 5% of boys cannot do this. However after puberty only about 1% are unable to retract their foreskin fully.

This inability may cause pain with erections and problems with sexual function.

This is the 1% of all boys who could benefit from a circumcision once assessed just prior to puberty at about age 10-12 years old.

The other medically indicated reason for circumcision is if the foreskin has pathological phimosis or otherwise an abnormal skin. This is usually in the form of scarring or thickening, secondary to infections or trauma. The incidence of this to occur is 0.1% of all boys.

With a normal foreskin, there is oily secretions and some dead cells which may collect under the foreskin and appears as white cheesy substance called smegma, especially if the foreskin cannot be retracted and the inside washed. This may get infected and the treatment for this is to sit your boy in a tub of warm salty water and some topical antibiotics cream from your doctor. Usually the foreskin will heal back to normal after a few days.

Boys should be taught to retract their foreskin in the shower to wash and when passing urine. With this daily practice and washing under the foreskin, infections can be avoided.

To circumcise or not has created much debate in the medical community worldwide. The timing of circumcision and risks and benefits of not being circumcised will be presented here, based on current available medical evidence and trends throughout the medical world.

Reasons NOT to circumcise without urgent medical reasons (excludes religious reasons)

  1. The foreskin has purpose. It keeps the head (glans) of the penis soft supple whilst a circumcised glans becomes keratinized (dry, skin like thickening)
  2. The foreskin is a complex, specialized tissue – a mobile, double-layered fold of skin, mucous membrane, and muscle, containing dense concentrations of erogenous nerve endings. It is an integral part of the penile skin system, not something “extra.”
  3. Circumcision is excruciatingly painful. When conducted on a newborn, the local anaesthesia is inadequate to fully anaesthetise the penis. Babies have continuing pain during the healing period, when the wound is exposed to faeces, urine, and irritation from the diaper. The diaper irritation also risks meatal stenosis (an abnormal narrowing of the urethral opening).
  4. Circumcision destroys the protective and sexual functions of the foreskin. Surgical complications are rare but includes: bleeding, infection, meatal stenosis, adhesions, death and loss of some parts of the penis, although rare, do occur. Some boys may have an excessive amount of skin left behind or some too little.
  5. Breastfeeding and the relationship of the mother and child after circumcision as a newborn may be impacted.
  6. Overall risk of any form of infections or any complications with a normal foreskin is about 0.1%. Whereas risks of any complications form circumcision is about 1%. With daily routine hygiene of the foreskin, risks are reduced and practicing safe sex as an adult will avoid of sexually transmitted diseases as an adult. It’s all about education, awareness and self-care.
  7. Most developed countries are going away from circumcising the normal penis, even in the US where previously most boys are circumcised at birth.

Benefits of Circumcision (excludes religious reasons)

  1. A decreased risk of urinary tract infections.
  2. A reduced risk of some sexually transmitted diseases in men. The world health organization recommends circumcision to reduce this risk.
  3. Prevention of balanitis (inflammation of the glans) and balanoposthitis (inflammation of the glans and foreskin).
  4. Prevention of phimosis (the inability to retract the foreskin) and paraphimosis (the inability to return the foreskin to its original location).
  5. Circumcision also makes it easier to keep the end of the penis clean.

In conclusion…

The debate goes on however, the bottom line is that it’s a personal choice to keep the foreskin or otherwise.

My personal view is that we should avoid circumcision for babies and offer the choice of circumcision to your boy at an age he could make his own mind up about his own body, closer to puberty. This is in keeping with the traditional age of cultural circumcision practiced in Malaysia.

Female circumcision is regarded as Genital Mutilation and it should not be practiced. There are no benefits whatsoever to this practice. Even the prick technique where a needle is used to pierce the skin, causes bleeding, pain and unnecessary trauma for the poor child and at the end of this there is scarring to where the skin was damaged.

Share this Post

Search Blog Posts

Dr Nada Sudhakaran

Paediatric Surgeon & Urologist

Paediatric Surgeon

Hospitals

Languages Spoken

Clinics Available

Pantai Hospital Kuala Lumpur

+603-2296 0419

Assunta Hospital PJ

+603-7872 3000

Follow Dr. Nada On Social

Patient Testimonials

Dr Nada Child Surgeon (Kuala Lumpur)Dr Nada Child Surgeon (Kuala Lumpur)5.0 Based on 182 reviews fromSee all reviewsMohd ShahrilMohd Shahril ★★★★★ Good consultation. Bagus & baik dlam mengendalikan kanak-kanakChelsea EmbChelsea Emb ★★★★★ Dr. Nada is a highly professional pediatrician. He provides clear and thorough medical advice. He is also extremely patient and kind with the children.We are truly grateful to have found such a caring and dedicated doctor. Thank you, Dr. Nada!Sadia HossainSadia Hossain ★★★★★ Dr Nada handled the case of my child really well. He was very good with my child to make them feel at ease and made the me reassured of the process he followed.hong familyhong family ★★★★★ Thank you Dr Nada for doing a successful appendix surgery for me.Dr Nada is very kind and caring.nenvy wantouwnenvy wantouw ★★★★★ Terima kasih dr. Nada, kedua anak laki-laki saya check up ke beliau, sangat puas dengan pemeriksaan yang dilakukan dr. Nada.Putri Ayu PratiwiPutri Ayu Pratiwi ★★★★★ Sangat baik, menjelaskan sangat rasional, menghilangkan kekhawatiran. Dokter terbaiklahAsweni GunasegranAsweni Gunasegran ★★★★★ We’ve had a truly wonderful experience with Dr. Nada. From our very first visit, it was clear that he is not only highly knowledgeable and experienced but also incredibly kind and patient with children.He took the time to listen to our problem, explain things clearly, and never make you feel rushed. My child was at ease and evenlooked forward to the next visit which says a lot!Thank you, Dr. Nada, for your dedication, warmth, and professionalism. We are truly grateful.Wong Hsien WeiWong Hsien Wei ★★★★★ Thank you, Dr. Nada, for your excellent care and support throughout our son’s treatment. He recently underwent keyhole surgery for a hernia, and everything went smoothly, just as you assured us.We were initially very worried about the anaesthesia, but you took the time to explain everything clearly and patiently, which helped us feel at ease.We’re truly glad we followed your advice to go with the minimally invasive approach, the recovery was quick, the pain was minimal, and the scarring was barely noticeable.Your professionalism and calm demeanour gave us great confidence, and we’re very grateful for the care you provided. ☺️👍Clarence Gretha ZetliecClarence Gretha Zetliec ★★★★★ The best doctor ever. He did a choledochal cyst surgery for my daughter, and it was incredible. I really Thank God I found him. Thank you so much doc!Jaya DevanJaya Devan ★★★★★ Friendly and a great doctor. Takes good care of patients. Felt really comfortable being his patient. Got a great treatment from him :)Caan Ee WongCaan Ee Wong ★★★★★ My daughter had a 6 hours keyhole surgery (choledochal cysts) performed by Dr. Nada. Time flies - it has already been a year since the surgery. Thanks to Dr. Nada’s professionalism, my girl is now able to live a normal life and has grown into such an active and sweet girl. Dr. Nada explained everything in detail during each of our visits. Thank you, Dr. Nada—we’re so grateful to know you.nurus sohwahnurus sohwah ★★★★★ I had an excellent experience with Dr. Nada at Pantai Hospital today for my baby's tongue tie treatment. Dr. Nada was incredibly professional, thorough, and caring throughout the process. He not only provided effective treatment but also took the time to teach us exercises to do at home over the next three weeks. The treatment is already showing great results, and I'm truly grateful for his expertise and support. I highly recommend Dr. Nada for anyone seeking care for tongue tie issues. Thank you so much for your excellent service!Tony TanTony Tan ★★★★★ Nice doctor 👍👍👍Dhinaashinee RajendranDhinaashinee Rajendran ★★★★★ We took our daughter in to see Dr. Nada for second opinion when she was diagnosed with inguinal hernia. The initial advise was to wait until she turned 60 weeks. Since she was a premie, they didn’t want to put her under anesthesia too soon. But after consulting with Dr. Nada, he told us to go for immediate surgery and we have no regrets about that decision.As first-time parents, we were nervous due to the difference in opinions about the timing of the surgery. But Dr. Nada and Dr. Uma, the neonatal paediatrician, patiently answered all our questions and eased our concerns.Our daughter did very well and she didn’t seem to be in any pain at all post surgery. We are so glad we chose to see Dr. Nada. He is very professional, responds to all our questions and thoroughly explained the entire process to us. Thank you, Dr. Nada.Simon LeeSimon Lee ★★★★★ Great Dr, soft spoken, friendly, encouraging.Clear details explanation. Highly recommended.ambareesh veerappaodayarambareesh veerappaodayar ★★★★★ Very Friendly and Experienced Doctor...RecommendedBeby Raven ShakeynBeby Raven Shakeyn ★★★★★ The best, super thorough, genuinely cared & explained my son’s condition so well. Would highly recommend Dr Nada to friends and family. Thank you Dr Nada!Vikhna RoobbanVikhna Roobban ★★★★★ best doctor ever!!!My baby was diagnosed at a medical center with a condition, and I was informed that surgery might be required to resolve the issue. However, they advised me to seek a pediatric surgeon elsewhere to perform the procedure. After searching online, I came across reviews about Dr. Nada. I contacted him via WhatsApp late at night, and he responded shortly afterward. We were given an appointment for the next day.During the consultation / physical examination, Dr. Nada carefully assessed my baby and confirmed that the condition do not require surgery and would resolve on its own as the baby grows. I was so relieved. The explanation provided about the condition was clear and easy to understand. We need more doctors like Dr.Nada❤️Yasmin YusoffYasmin Yusoff ★★★★★ Dr Nada explained well with pictures and slides so we could understand better about my baby’s inguinal hernia condition and keyhole surgery.He answered all my questions and concerns and also responded via phone when he was on leave.My baby is recovering well from the surgery. So thank you so much!jugal joshijugal joshi ★★★★★ Doctor Nada and his clinic were extremely pleasant and helpful!Ben OngBen Ong ★★★★★ Smooth procedure and very incredibly friendlyTong KetTong Ket ★★★★★ Doctor very friendly and nice. Thank you 🙏🏻Yessy LimYessy Lim ★★★★★ Thank you Dr.Nadarajan for helping us..I am from Indonesia, my baby was diagnosed with Hirschsprung's disease, after surgery at 2 months old and now my baby is healthy now..Lyndesa KoonLyndesa Koon ★★★★★ Dr Nada is one of the best paed surgeon I’ve met. When I found out my 2 months old daughter have inguinal hernia from my paed, I researched and found Dr Nada’s website, directly WhatsApp him in the middle of the night on my baby’s condition to get his advice. He was very prompt and replied early in the morning to scheduled for a check up. He gave us the assurance that the surgery will be fine for her despite being just 2 months old & was born as a premmie. We took a leap of faith & believed in him with his years of experience, did the surgery the day after. A week after the recovery, my baby is all in smiles and sleeps very well at night no more straining and grunting in pain. I am very thankful and counting my blessing. Thank you Dr Nada.Rizwaan MazirRizwaan Mazir ★★★★★ Dr Nada is very knowledgeable in paediatric surgeon.. give a full detailed explanation in overall. Dr. Nada also very kind and child friendly.. see you tomorrow Dr for next appointment..Hendro ChandraHendro Chandra ★★★★★ Very glad we meet the right doctor with his speciality and experience doing the keyhole surgery to our 2yo daughter (hernia inguinalis). No doubt the best one, thankyou doctor nada. While in the waiting room, there was one patient sharing her experience after fourth surgery with doctor and convinced us that we found the right doctor for our case.Elly YbElly Yb ★★★★★ Doktor yang bagus,mantap sekali..Yau HunYau Hun ★★★★★ My child had surgery here performed by Dr. Nada and has been following up for a few years. The doctor is empathetic, patient, ethical, and professional, and the nurse is also very attentive and kind.Christini HooChristini Hoo ★★★★★ Dr Nada is a very good, assuring and experienced doctor. We are glad can meet a doctor like himAshley ZulkapeliAshley Zulkapeli ★★★★★ Accomodating, kind, detailed explanation. Could see why hes getting excellent reviews. Kind nursing staffs too!Danny KoayDanny Koay ★★★★★ Very experience doctor and professional. Highly recommended.Donna OctaviaDonna Octavia ★★★★★ Dokter Nada is very nice, professional & very very very detailed! I would definitely come back and see him whenever theres problems with my son. Thank you so much doctor! 🥰Cyrus WongCyrus Wong ★★★★★ I am so glad that I was referred to Dr Nada when I found out my 2 month old son was diagnosed with inguinal hernia. Dr Nada has always been calm and reassuring, he listens and explains things patiently and thoroughly. My son’s keyhole surgery went very well and he is recovering fast. Thank you so much!Nur HafizahNur Hafizah ★★★★★ Dr Nada was extremely kind and patient. He was reassuring and didn’t suggest unnecessary interventions. Definitely one of the best Paeds surgeons around!Jose Luis LarrosaJose Luis Larrosa ★★★★★ Dr. Nada is an exceptional pediatrician who combines professionalism with a warm, friendly demeanor that immediately puts both parents and children at ease. From the moment you walk into his office, it's clear that he genuinely cares about the well-being of his young patients. His gentle approach and patience in explaining everything to both parents and children are truly commendable.Ram GollapalliRam Gollapalli ★★★★★ Doctor is very friendly and treated well. My kid got Hernia surgery, after we talked to Dr Nada we felt so relax and everything went well. He gavemany suggestions and answered all our doubts. I m strongly recommending.Thanks a lot Dr Nada.Saidatul SyafiqahSaidatul Syafiqah ★★★★★ The Dr is superb with his explaination and consultation. The wording and terms that he uses to explain is easier to understand for us as a parents with no medical background. We have come to the right place. If we can give hundred stars of rating, we would definitely give it happily. Thanks you much Dr!niki khorniki khor ★★★★★ Dr. Nada 是一位非常有耐心的医生,他乐意解答父母的每一个疑问。他的细心和耐心让父母对他充满信心,令我们愿意将孩子百分之百地交给他。手术后,他会亲自检查孩子的伤口,并与家人沟通孩子的康复进展以及接下来的治疗计划。这种关怀和沟通让家人感到放心和安心。js_loader

Latest Posts

Schedule An Appointment

Set up an appointment with Dr. Nada and he’ll be able to assess your child to ensure they receive the care they need.

Or fill up the form below

Clinic Locations & Hours

Pantai Hospital
(Kuala Lumpur)
Assunta Hospital
(Petaling Jaya)

Stay Informed About Your Child's Health - For FREE!

Subscribe to my EMAIL newsletter and receive occassional emails from me containing my latest articles and videos about paediatric health matters that can help your child lead a safe and healthy life.